--- title: The Rabbi and the Roof description: The Rabbi and the Roof image: https://blog.jewishphilly.org/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/GIF-4.gif --- [![Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia](https://blog.jewishphilly.org/hubfs/JewishFederation_May2019/images/logo--color.svg)](https://jewishphilly.org/) - [Philly Stands With Israel](https://go.jewishphilly.org/philly-stands-with-israel) - - [Donate to Philly Stands with Israel Fund](https://donate.jewishphilly.org/page/66252/donate/1) - [Community Resources](https://jewishphilly.org/philly-stands-with-israel-resources/) - [Emergency Allocations](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/donate-emergency-response-fund/emergency-allocations/) - - [Advocate](https://jewishphilly.org/philly-stands-with-israel-resources/advocate/) - [Israel in the News](https://go.jewishphilly.org/israel-in-the-news) - [Sign up for Israel Emergency Emails](https://go.jewishphilly.org/israel-emergency-emails) - [Who We Are](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/) - - [About](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/about/) - [History](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/history/) - [Our Impact](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/our-impact/) - [Financials](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/financials/) - [Program Evaluation](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/program-evaluation/) - - [Leadership & Governance](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/leadership/) - [Ethics and Organizational Oversight](https://jewishphilly.org/ethics-and-organizational-oversight/) - [Careers](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/careers/) - [Contact Us](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/contact-us/) - [Sign Up for Emails](https://go.jewishphilly.org/jewish-federation-email-sign-up) - [Ways to Give](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/) - - [Donate Now](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/donate-now/) - [Give Monthly](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/give-monthly/) - [Donate a Vehicle](https://jewishphilly.careasy.org/HOME.html) - [Jewish Community Foundation](https://blog.jewishphilly.org/Jewish%20Community%20Foundation) - [Life & Legacy Program](https://jewishphilly.org/life-and-legacy/) - - [Philanthropic Donor Advised Funds](https://jewishphilly.giftplans.org/index.php?cID=247) - [Tribute E-Cards](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/tribute-cards/) - [Giving Societies](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/giving-societies/) - [EITC](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/eitc/) - - Your gift matters. - Your donation to the Jewish Federation has a big impact, rippling through our community and around the world, providing resources to meet urgent needs today and build a bright future. - [Get Involved](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/) - - [Events Calendar](https://jewishphilly.org/events-calendar) - [Signature Events](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/signature-events/) - [Affinity Groups](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/affinity-groups/) - [Volunteer](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/volunteer/) - - [Neighborhood (Kehillot) Programming](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/neighborhood-programming/) - [Mission Trips](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/missions/) - [Jewish Professionals Organization (JPRO)](https://jewishphilly.org/jpro/) - [Resources](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/) - - [Supporting Ukraine](https://go.jewishphilly.org/supporting-ukraine) - [COVID-19 Relief](https://go.jewishphilly.org/combatting-covid-19) - [Population Study](https://jewishphilly.org/communityportrait/) - [Mitzvah Food Program](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/mitzvah-food-program/) - [Teen Programs](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/teen-programs/) - [Jewish Camping](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/jewish-camping/) - - [Scholarships](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/scholarships/) - [Jewish Community Relations Council](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/public-affairs/) - [Israel Engagement](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/israel-engagement/) - [Holocaust Education](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/holocaust-programming/) - [Apply for Grants](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/apply-for-grants/) - [Security](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/security/) - [News](https://go.jewishphilly.org/news) - [Philly Stands With Israel](https://go.jewishphilly.org/philly-stands-with-israel) - - [Donate to Philly Stands with Israel Fund](https://donate.jewishphilly.org/page/66252/donate/1) - [Community Resources](https://jewishphilly.org/philly-stands-with-israel-resources/) - [Emergency Allocations](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/donate-emergency-response-fund/emergency-allocations/) - - [Advocate](https://jewishphilly.org/philly-stands-with-israel-resources/advocate/) - [Israel in the News](https://go.jewishphilly.org/israel-in-the-news) - [Sign up for Israel Emergency Emails](https://go.jewishphilly.org/israel-emergency-emails) - [Who We Are](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/) - - [About](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/about/) - [History](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/history/) - [Our Impact](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/our-impact/) - [Financials](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/financials/) - [Program Evaluation](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/program-evaluation/) - - [Leadership & Governance](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/leadership/) - [Ethics and Organizational Oversight](https://jewishphilly.org/ethics-and-organizational-oversight/) - [Careers](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/careers/) - [Contact Us](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/contact-us/) - [Sign Up for Emails](https://go.jewishphilly.org/jewish-federation-email-sign-up) - [Ways to Give](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/) - - [Donate Now](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/donate-now/) - [Give Monthly](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/give-monthly/) - [Donate a Vehicle](https://jewishphilly.careasy.org/HOME.html) - [Jewish Community Foundation](https://blog.jewishphilly.org/Jewish%20Community%20Foundation) - [Life & Legacy Program](https://jewishphilly.org/life-and-legacy/) - - [Philanthropic Donor Advised Funds](https://jewishphilly.giftplans.org/index.php?cID=247) - [Tribute E-Cards](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/tribute-cards/) - [Giving Societies](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/giving-societies/) - [EITC](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/eitc/) - - Your gift matters. - Your donation to the Jewish Federation has a big impact, rippling through our community and around the world, providing resources to meet urgent needs today and build a bright future. - [Get Involved](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/) - - [Events Calendar](https://jewishphilly.org/events-calendar) - [Signature Events](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/signature-events/) - [Affinity Groups](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/affinity-groups/) - [Volunteer](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/volunteer/) - - [Neighborhood (Kehillot) Programming](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/neighborhood-programming/) - [Mission Trips](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/missions/) - [Jewish Professionals Organization (JPRO)](https://jewishphilly.org/jpro/) - [Resources](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/) - - [Supporting Ukraine](https://go.jewishphilly.org/supporting-ukraine) - [COVID-19 Relief](https://go.jewishphilly.org/combatting-covid-19) - [Population Study](https://jewishphilly.org/communityportrait/) - [Mitzvah Food Program](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/mitzvah-food-program/) - [Teen Programs](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/teen-programs/) - [Jewish Camping](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/jewish-camping/) - - [Scholarships](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/scholarships/) - [Jewish Community Relations Council](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/public-affairs/) - [Israel Engagement](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/israel-engagement/) - [Holocaust Education](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/holocaust-programming/) - [Apply for Grants](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/apply-for-grants/) - [Security](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/security/) - [News](https://go.jewishphilly.org/news) [Donate](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/donate-now/) [Donate](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/donate-now/) [Newsletter](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/newsletter/) [Login](https://jewishphilly.org/login/) [Board Login](https://jewishphilly.org/board-login/) Search Search the site: Search the site: [Newsletter](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/newsletter/) [Login](https://jewishphilly.org/login/) [Board Login](https://jewishphilly.org/board-login/) Search ## Jewish Philly Blog ![The Rabbi and the Roof](https://blog.jewishphilly.org/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/GIF-4.gif) ## March 2, 2018 # The Rabbi and the Roof ![](https://blog.jewishphilly.org/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/GIF-1.gif) The great scholar Rabbi Yisrael Salanter didn’t *look* like a radical; he carried himself with humility and dressed like an ordinary 19th century shtetl Jew. But with his vast *halachic* knowledge, extraordinary sense of empathy, knack for divergent thinking and readiness to spring into action, he both inspired and challenged his Lithuanian followers. During the 1848 cholera epidemic that swept Vilna, for example, Salanter declared that on Yom Kippur, as an emergency measure to prevent further loss of life, it was imperative that Jews not fast in observance of the holiday. Lest anyone be shy about following his suggestion, Salanter set a personal example. He stood behind the pulpit after the Kol Nidre prayer and, before the widened eyes of the shocked congregation, recited *Kiddush*, then ate and drank. That was Rav Salanter’s way. ![](https://blog.jewishphilly.org/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/GIF-2.gif) Salanter would go on to become the father of the *Mussar* movement, the Jewish practice of ethical living through self-improvement, and travelled across Lithuania, Prussia and Germany to spread his message. So it was that one winter’s day, Salanter arrived in a new town. He was greeted by the elders, who invited him to stay in their shtetl’s grandest home. But while walking through town, Salanter noticed the poorhouse. Its roof was in shambles: sagging dangerously in some places and with gaping holes in others that let in the wind and snow. ![](https://blog.jewishphilly.org/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/GIF-3.gif) Seeing Salanter’s troubled expression, the town elders explained that they eventually planned to raise money for repairs. Salanter cracked open the poorhouse door. The beggars, the sick and the poor travelers who crowded the floor were hugging themselves against the cold, freezing and wheezing. *“I will sleep here,” Salanter declared.* The elders protested, but Salanter remained resolute. He had allowed himself to see what the elders had not: that the people taking refuge inside were, like him, human beings made *b’tzelem elohim* — in G-d’s image — with needs as urgent as his own. “If such conditions are good enough for them, they will be good enough for me,” Salanter told the elders. ![](https://blog.jewishphilly.org/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/GIF-4.gif) And there on the frozen poorhouse ground slept the great Rav Salanter, night after night, until the elders announced they had raised the funds for a new roof. *When you are compassionate, you allow the sight of suffering to break your heart and compel you to take action.* [See More Attributes](https://jfed.demo.cshp.co/youarejewishfederation/) Share [Share on Facebook](http://www.facebook.com/share.php?u=https://blog.jewishphilly.org/the-rabbi-and-the-roof&title=The%20Rabbi%20and%20the%20Roof) [Share on Twitter](http://twitter.com/home?status=The%20Rabbi%20and%20the%20Roof+https://blog.jewishphilly.org/the-rabbi-and-the-roof) [Share by Email](mailto:?subject=The%20Rabbi%20and%20the%20Roof&body=The%20Rabbi%20and%20the%20Roof%20-%20https://blog.jewishphilly.org/the-rabbi-and-the-roof) ### Sign up for the *Jewish Philly* E-Newsletter [Back to The Latest](https://blog.jewishphilly.org) [Tweets by JFedinPhilly](https://twitter.com/JFedinPhilly?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw) ## Find us on ![JFGP_KO_rgb](https://blog.jewishphilly.org/hs-fs/hubfs/JFGP_KO_rgb.png?width=300&height=84&name=JFGP_KO_rgb.png) Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia Two Commerce Square 2001 Market Street, Suite 2300 Philadelphia, PA 19103 [215.832.0500](tel:1-215-832-0500) | [info@jewishphilly.org](mailto:info@jewishphilly.org) *The Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia welcomes the participation of Jews across the religious spectrum, interfaith couples and families, and people of all abilities, backgrounds, gender identities, and sexual orientations. If you require special accommodations, please contact us, and we will make every effort to meet your needs.* © 2024 Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia. All Rights Reserved. [Privacy Policy](https://jewishphilly.org/privacy-policy) | [Contact Us](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/contact-us) A 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organization. EIN: 23-1500085 [![Four-Star-Rating-Badge-Full-Color](https://blog.jewishphilly.org/hs-fs/hubfs/Four-Star-Rating-Badge-Full-Color.webp?width=150&height=150&name=Four-Star-Rating-Badge-Full-Color.webp)](https://jewishphilly.org/4-star-charity-navigator-rating/)   - [Who We Are](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/) - [About](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/about/) - [History](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/history/) - [Our Impact](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/our-impact/) - [Leadership & Governance](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/leadership/) - [Financials](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/financials/) - [Program Evaluation](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/program-evaluation/) - [Contact Us](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/contact-us/) - [Sign Up for Emails](https://go.jewishphilly.org/jewish-federation-email-sign-up) - [Careers](https://jewishphilly.org/who-we-are/careers/) - [Get Involved](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/) - [Events Calendar](https://jewishphilly.org/events-calendar) - [Signature Events](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/signature-events/) - [Affinity Groups](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/affinity-groups/) - [Volunteer](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/volunteer/) - [Jewish Community Relations Council](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/public-affairs/) - [Travel with Purpose](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/missions/) - [Neighborhood Programming](https://jewishphilly.org/get-involved/neighborhood-programming/) - [The Latest](https://go.jewishphilly.org/news) - [Blog](https://blog.jewishphilly.org) - [Press Room](https://jewishphilly.org/category/press-room/) - [Ways to Give](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/) - [Donate Now](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/donate-now/) - [Give Monthly](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/give-monthly/) - [Jewish Community Foundation](https://jfgp.giftlegacy.com/) - [Life & Legacy Program](https://jewishphilly.org/life-and-legacy/) - [Tribute E-Cards](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/tribute-cards/) - [Giving Societies](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/giving-societies/) - [EITC](https://jewishphilly.org/ways-to-give/eitc/) - [Resources](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/) - [COVID-19 Relief](https://go.jewishphilly.org/combatting-covid-19) - [Population Study](https://jewishphilly.org/communityportrait/) - [Mitzvah Food Program](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/mitzvah-food-program/) - [Teen Programs](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/teen-programs/) - [Jewish Camping](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/jewish-camping/) - [Apply for Grants](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/apply-for-grants/) - [Scholarships](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/scholarships/) - [Israel Engagement](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/israel-engagement/) - [Holocaust Education](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/holocaust-programming/) - [Security](https://jewishphilly.org/resources/security/)